Present tense narrative really doesn't have a place in fiction writing. Ironically, like Game of Thrones, this might indeed make for good television, so I’m not saying don’t watch it, but don’t feel bad about not reading the book(s).Ĭreate a website or blog at WordPress.Past tense, people. I have a horrible feeling there will be sequels. If a meteor shower had hit every habitat and killed everyone, I wouldn’t have been bothered. It’s another science fiction menippean satire, a series of meetings between characters who exchange views, but there isn’t much of a plot, and the climax ends up being both rushed and boring, with nobody to root for and nothing much to care about.

There are lots of names: sons and daughters and second sons and more sons and daughters, and arranged marriages and custody battles over their kids, but it all ends up a big wash of interchangeable people who have walk-on parts, or pop up here and there, but not so much that you start caring about them. And though the stakes are meant to be high and lives are at risk, the fact that it’s so easy to die on the moon lowered the stakes. It’s worse, even, than playing Monopoly: it’s watching other people play monopoly. The thing about business, for me, is that it just isn’t very interesting. There are arranged marriages, court cases, secret societies, and more – but I wasn’t interested in any of it. Each family has a monopoly of some particular resource, but the Cortas and the McKenzies are at each others throats because their businesses overlap in some way. The main focus here is the Corta family, of Brazilian origin, who are competing – in some unspecified way – with other corporate families who originate from Russia, China, Nigeria, and Australia.

I’m not particularly interested in their polymorphous sexualities, their fashions, designer drugs, or much else about this society. But here’s the thing: I don’t care about any of the dynasties, any of the people, or their business ambitions. There are sections of this novel I have in fact read before, in short story collections, and the novel seems to have been constructed around these fragments. The novels seem soulless to me, written in an affectless style, as if put together by a committee.Īnd I did not enjoy reading Luna. I’ve said before that while I love the TV series (occasional pacing issues notwithstanding), I did not enjoy reading the novels. It’s about a murderous and deadly frontier where there is no law except contract law and where there are a thousand ways to die. You can see what is meant by that: this is a novel about near-future industrial dynasties on a commercialised and privatised Moon.

According to its Wikipedia entry, this novel has been called Game of Thrones in space.

Ian mcdonald luna